Leeds Rumours Member Posts

 

OptimistPesimistt's Profile


Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded

OptimistPesimistt's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To OptimistPesimistt's Posts

 

 

To OptimistPesimistt's last 5 rumours posts

 

To OptimistPesimistt's last 5 banter posts

 

To OptimistPesimistt's last 5 rumour replies

 

To OptimistPesimistt's last 5 banter replies

 

OptimistPesimistt's rumours posts with other poster's replies to OptimistPesimistt's rumours posts

 

30 Oct 2026 09:47:22
I'm finding the reports this morning that Man United are poised to snap up Calvert Lewin in January completely ridiculous.
Yeah we'll sell him to them and make a nice profit and have no adapted striker to slot into his place.


Meanwhile we are struggling in the relegation zone.
I'm not saying that the club "might" cash in on him in the summer, but in January is just laughable.

OptimistPesimistt

1.) 30 Oct 2026 10:07:35
I actually don't think it's laughable. I think every player has a price. Ofc for him to go there it would be astronomical for:

DcL recent form and durability improvement.
It being January
It being Manchester united as a rival
It being Manchester united in desperate need

If I were our recruitment team (they'll have been doing this anyway) I'd be lining up contingencies to replace DCL. He has 18 months left on his deal. We've had his fittest season and a half in nearly a decade it feels like. It still feels like we hit a jackpot on that and it won't last.

Now I'm not about to say take a cut price £40m for him no. They'll moan and complain about £90m but that is what id start at with all the circumstances. And if we're not with a good points total by then, it won't matter we won't sell. They should baulk at £90m and move on. If we're in a good place £90m rebuilds the forward line.


2.) 30 Oct 2026 13:08:52
I think it's absolutely wrong to even think of quoting a price, even one as high as £90M. We all know that MU could easily afford that much and would quite likely agree to pay even that high a price to solve their temporary problem. Our response should be that he's not for sale, so talking values is pointless, and please just b####r off.


In any case DCL himself would most probably reject the idea of moving from a happy squad to a rabble where he knows he'd only be seen as a stopgap until Sesko is fit again or another high price star could be found.


3.) 30 Oct 2026 13:18:41
7th and "Struggling in the relegation zone" OP, really!


4.) 30 Oct 2026 14:09:53
#clickbait.


5.) 30 Oct 2026 16:55:59
Mebbe a bit more than clickbait Baz, seems to me like someone over there starting a rumour to guage the reaction, best to ignore it.


6.) 31 Oct 2026 08:51:18
I'd sell him for 45 We gonna spend about 30-50 on striker and am in Jan anyway. That 35 would give us more dosh to offer. That's 45 clear profit. It's not personal. Just business. Logic.


 

 

02 Sep 2026 20:26:47
A lot of comments being made about the attempted approach of Sunderland for Noah Okafor yesterday.
Rumours made of 35 Mil offered, I don't believe for one second Sunderland offered that amount if at all.
One thing I do know is that Okafor is an asset to the club, whether he's a sixty minute man or not, for me I definitely want him to stay.

We've seen recently that he's been given a more central role which he seems to benefit.
I think he welcomes Bahoya's inclusion. Nothing like a healthy competitive spirit in the squad.

OptimistPesimistt

1.) 02 Sep 2026 22:35:31
The offer was reported by the local press in both Leeds and Sunderland as £30M or €35M. Like you, I was surprised at the amount, but can only go on the information available. He joined us last year from AC Milan for £17M, so if another club are prepared to offer us nearly double that, it tells us we have a valuable asset on our hands.


2.) 02 Sep 2026 22:48:35
Okafor was our 2nd highest scorer last seez, so him playing more central this seez might prove even more fruitful from a goals perspective.

As for Bahoya, if he is even half as good as the previous forward Mr Tony Yeboah, that Leeds United signed from Eintracht Frankfurt, then we are in for some exciting fireworks. ?


3.) 03 Sep 2026 01:10:48
Ah, Tony Yeboah, what memories. That man never scored a boring goal; most were 20+ yard blockbusters. I recall one famous example against Liverpool. Dominic Matteo was playing for Liverpool that day, and later said that all he could recall was it flying over his head, and thinking that David James was not going to stop it - and he didn't!


4.) 03 Sep 2026 02:21:48
I heard it reported that a number of clubs asked about him, and the best offer from that group was in the region of 35 million, so not necessarily from Sunderland.

One of the elite WACCOE ITK's actually stated early in the summer that Leeds would consider a deal for him if a good offer came in.

For a player with one assist last season, and who cannot complete a game, I'd be onboard with that. Could have been a fine time to sell, and selling better is most certainly something the club have needed to do for decades.


5.) 03 Sep 2026 07:20:24
Had we got the offer earlier in the window, I think we would have taken it, but with low squad numbers, lack of left-sided and ST cover, and uncertainty about Bahoya, we would have been daft to accept on the final day.


6.) 03 Sep 2026 07:43:28
The best news out of all of this, is that He wanted to stay! As Frogus alluded to, I don't believe the actual offer was from Sunderland, but someone else. Sunderland enquired about his availability and were given short shrift, rightly, at that stage of the window.


7.) 03 Sep 2026 09:58:56
I got the impression, and alluded to it a month or so ago, that Noah was being looked at as backup to DCL. This is kinda backed up by the lack of signings in that area. Is it possible that Daniel Farke may be looking at him reverting to his original role?


8.) 03 Sep 2026 11:00:53
He was our second top scorer last season, and, having decided to bring in a new left winger, and not the new central striker many of us clamoured for (me included) , it seems he may adopt a more central role. With ongoing injury fears about DCL and Nmecha, selling him isn't something I'd have considered at all, let alone on deadline day.

He's not a natural winger, so his assist tally isn't good, but he is a good finisher, given the opportunity, so this season could be a new beginning for him, and I'm sure the fitness coaches will be trying to improve his stamina.


9.) 03 Sep 2026 11:25:39
Interesting posts above. Food for thought. And, Wimbledon Baz.


10.) 03 Sep 2026 14:01:47
Someone offers us 35million two weeks ago, and we would have sold him and bought Paixao. Three awful crosses at the weekend on his left foot, very low assist record, and cannot do more than 60 mins. Too many basing him on two goals at OT.


11.) 03 Sep 2026 14:15:38
Yeah Aus, Yeboah's goal vs Wimbledon was a unique, perfect work of art.


12.) 03 Sep 2026 14:17:19
Okafor over Ox cubes. Why?
One does. One never did.


13.) 03 Sep 2026 14:20:06
I do not believe that any club offered Leeds United £35 million for Okafor.

And, FrogMax, give over on the Paxo cubes to Leeds' imaginary stuff. It's evident Paxo never wanted to come to Leeds, nor Sunderland and others for that matter.

It was never ever going to happen!


14.) 03 Sep 2026 14:27:39
Basing it on his past position, not 2 goals!


 

 

01 Sep 2026 08:47:30
Leeds I for Melvin Bard LB from OGC Nice.

OptimistPesimistt

1.) 01 Sep 2026 21:54:57
What happened to this, then? BBC seemed to think it was practically a done deal earlier on?


 

 

27 May 2026 19:45:28
Looking likely and not a surprise that Sebastiaan Bornauw will be heading back to the Bundesliga to join FC Koln.
Can’t see him being sold for any more than he was bought for which I believe was 5Mil.

OptimistPesimistt

 

 

05 May 2026 08:02:33
Rumours of John Stones being a possible free transfer to Leeds this summer. Everton are also linked.
At 31 years old and injuries taking its toll on his aging body, I’m not sure we’d be interested in him.
Possibly a promoted team might take him on especially with his impressive experience in the Premiership.

OptimistPesimistt

1.) 05 May 2026 12:35:09
If the medical team can manage him as they have DCL, then as you say, his experience and ability to play from the back would be very beneficial. His wages at Citeh must be astronomical tho!?


2.) 05 May 2026 16:54:49
Yes, he is on £250k a week currently, but he must realise he won't get that at his age with any other EPL side.


3.) 06 May 2026 21:15:13
I speculated that we'd be too far down the totem pole for him. I also think that unless he'd take a massive paycut, he wouldn't be worth it for Leeds.

A two year deal - with a third year vesting option after 20 appearances in the final season @70K a week, is the absolute most I'd stretch to for him. I imagine he'd get far better offers than that, and fair enough. I think he's a Villa/Newcastle signing at 120k two years, or maybe Everton at 100K two years.

If we wanted to take a punt on an injury prone cb, I'd offer Adam Webster a one-year deal at 35K a week, with a vesting second year on appearances. He'd take the Bornauw backup role, but likely a 10-15% depth upgrade.

I think this would be a very different situation from DCL, aside from them both being free agents.

Central defence is very much a strength for us with Joe, Bijol, Struijk, Justin, Ampadu, and Bornauw in that order. In that list, on current evidence, he wouldn't even be no.1 or no.2 for me. He'd slot in on par with Struijk, so very good but not first on the team sheet for the position, which it would have to be to be worth it. With DCL, it was a thin market in our budget for a centre forward that we desperately needed an upgrade in that position.

Doekhi (impending free agent) .
Anel Ahmedhodzic (former Sheffield United) , est. cost £12-15m, suits our system, prem experience at Sheffield, 6'3.
Mavropanos if West Ham get relegated.
Axel Disasi if Chelsea decide to sell after his West Ham loan is up.
Ben Davies (more the Byram utility replacement) .


4.) 07 May 2026 06:44:04
If we're looking at Japanese players, Ayase Ueda has got an impressive scoring record at Feyenoord.


5.) 17 May 2026 23:18:05
Can we not keep Tanaka?


 

 

 

OptimistPesimistt's banter posts with other poster's replies to OptimistPesimistt's banter posts

 

08 Nov 2026 18:38:22
Carrick is just the gift that keeps on giving, absolutely fantastic stuff, how many more turds can he pluck out the toilet bowl.
I'm really impressed in his persistence of seeing Man united being relegated.
Top bloke. ??.

OptimistPesimistt

1.) 08 Nov 2026 19:18:00
I didnt expect Man U would be 19th but to be fair its been a decent week of comebacks for Carrick

Man U came back to win 3 -2 in midweek and came back to draw 4 -4 with Villa with 2 injury time goals

19th though lol.


2.) 08 Nov 2026 21:06:50
They're 18th Baz not 19th. I doubt they will be down there after 20 games or so but I agree with OP, it's hilarious right now.
Loving it!!


3.) 08 Nov 2026 21:39:24
Yep indeed Yeboah correct Man U are 18th not 19th. and likely to climb higher

I am pretty sure OP wasnt aware of Man Utd last minute draw thinking Villa had won.


4.) 09 Nov 2026 02:38:55
With the mid season transfer window coming up, it seems like every other day we see rumours linking them with yet another striker. I keep wondering how long it will be before it dawns on them that they've already got some decent strikers, but also a ropey goalkeeper and a bunch of crap defenders.

Were it not for the amateurish defending, they may well have won against Villa. Nice to see them in the drop zone, but i doubt they'll still be there at the end of the season.


 

 

08 Nov 2026
New image uploaded to the
Leeds Player Sightings page entitled, In defense of Leeds United this was a clear penalty

Click picture for larger image

OptimistPesimistt

1.) 08 Nov 2026 10:43:30
Looks clear cut from that still but from side elevation point of contact looks as it hits his front delt, either way arms in a totally unnatural position.

So another Var dubious call.


2.) 08 Nov 2026 10:55:30
Nah. Hit his shoulder. That's the wrong angle.


3.) 08 Nov 2026 11:52:14
Simular position to DCL's goal that was ruled out by VAR against Bournemouth.


4.) 08 Nov 2026 12:41:07
His arm is in that position for balance to chest the ball back. If he tucked it behind his body he would pretty much face plant. Get over it. It wasn't a penalty.


5.) 08 Nov 2026 14:31:43
More the thought process was, stop that ball with my arm, the head position shows it clearly.
Not needing to get over it just in the comfort that knowing it was a pen.


6.) 08 Nov 2026 16:35:43
Umm a photo can be very deceptive OP.
You've seen the video footage from more relevant angles.nuff said. keep it real.


7.) 08 Nov 2026 17:24:22
Reality is in my own head Baz not yours.


8.) 09 Nov 2026 12:12:52
I've seen the video footage from a few different angles and am still not convinced that it shouldn't have been a pen. Certainly his body position shows that he "intended" to contact the ball with his chest not his arm, but did he or did he not succeed, that is the question.

As Mezman said, if that ain't a pen, then DCLs disallowed goal at Bournemouth should've stood.


 

 

07 Nov 2026 18:23:08
Farke a tad lucky with that change of formation. A poor first half and Bogle should’ve been sent off, never seen such an obvious red card, VAR must have been drunk or blind.
Farke getting let off in this game with this lucky win.

Trafford didn’t really show enough quality keeping to warrant his hefty 45Mil price tag, personally I expect more from him.

Yes we won but were very fortunate and I doubt we’ll be as lucky in our next game after the international break.

A must win game at Chelsea after the break, Farke has to get this right now that he has stumbled on a new formation which was well overdue.

If we don’t qualify for a European competition, this season will be a failure.

#Standards.
Have a good evening, if you can ?

OptimistPesimistt

1.) 07 Nov 2026 18:42:02
Good to see Farkey taking the wise advice of playing Nmecha and DCL from the start

100% win rate doing this.

Onwards and upwards.


2.) 07 Nov 2026 18:54:56
Very good OP.


3.) 07 Nov 2026 19:34:00
You being serious Corky? this is what he does yet when anyone does something similar he's up in arms and off on another tangent and within a few millimetres of another meltdown ?.


4.) 07 Nov 2026 19:49:38
I love it OP ??.


5.) 07 Nov 2026 19:54:23
Chris, I don't do meltdowns but I'm very happy that you guys know how to do a good ol' fashioned lip wobble on here regularly, keeps me busy on this forum. ??.


6.) 07 Nov 2026 20:15:13
You can tell yourself that all day long OP
But..???.


7.) 07 Nov 2026 20:57:24
Tongue in cheek Chris.
If OP wants to work this way and possibly alienate certain posters then that's his choice.


8.) 07 Nov 2026 21:15:20
Nice OP ??.


9.) 07 Nov 2026 21:55:10
Nice one Corkey, my aim is not to alienate myself from other posters, just to have a bit of fun and banter.

And what's not to like other than a great Leeds United victory which im pretty certain we are all ecstatic about today ⚽️?
That is something surely that we all can share.


10.) 08 Nov 2026 19:57:40
At the end of the day like Baz said, I'm just glad that Farke took the advice, possibly from disgruntled posters on this forum to change his formation, not before time I say.


 

 

03 Nov 2026 20:54:49
Such a satisfying sensation when Man U players and coach are booed off the pitch at half time.
I’m almost getting bored in reveling in such abysmal football from them.
But no way will I ever feel sympathy ?

OptimistPesimistt

1.) 03 Nov 2026 21:53:06
I was going to say we definitely agree on this OP. But it looks like you may have preemptively jinxed it again as Man U have come back from 2 nil down at HT to lead 3 -2.oops

Well at least Raphinha 's talent was way too much for Villa.


2.) 03 Nov 2026 22:04:04
Good news that they win Baz, gives Carrick a stay of reprieve, I'm sure the hierarchy were hoping he'd fail tonight to pave the way more smoothly for the Man U fans favorite to be replaced by Howe.

Just gives Carrick's stay of execution a while longer to drag Muck Utd further into the relegation zone.
Happy days as far as I see it.


3.) 03 Nov 2026 22:13:00
Yep agree with all of that OP.


4.) 03 Nov 2026 22:19:39
Long may Carrick remain at Old Trafford - just long enough to take them to the point of no return in the Premiership. :) ) )


5.) 04 Nov 2026 08:02:22
Agree your sentiments Cleggy, but I doubt he'll be given that long. Unless there's a marked improvement in the next 2 or 3 games he's toast.


6.) 04 Nov 2026 13:29:25
I fear you are right JR.

Be lovely to see them go though!


7.) 04 Nov 2026 14:30:24
I'm old enough to remember one of our best seasons ever (the very best IMO) in 1973/74 when we finished as 1st Div champions, and they were relegated.


8.) 04 Nov 2026 14:33:48
I think it's a good thing they won too. They got a sniff of a chance after a controversial penalty award and even more controversial retake.

But that squad isn't capable of playing three games in eight days to the intensity they showed in the second half.

Villa were finished by the hour so they took off Manzambi and mcginn on 62 and Jackson for the last 15. Little game management bits like that make the difference in keeping players sharp Vs fatigued.

In such a congested fixture list if you're more than two down to a leading team and a big game at the weekend absolutely rest the stars. Not everyone will agree with that.


9.) 05 Nov 2026 05:10:20
Good point re villa bkb. Good management.


 

 

31 Oct 2026 17:25:10
Both teams were really poor, rubbish game for the fans.
The result should have been a nil nil draw contrary to what I thought.
What can you do when you gift the opposition with a goal.
Lack of decent passing yet again our downfall.
That final third appears to be a very difficult phase for us to deal with atmo, keeps fizzling out with bad decisions and passes.

Thought we were doing reasonably well until Trafford's error, it gave Bournemouth momentum which made it much harder for us.
Second half I almost fell asleep from an entertainment point of view.
Bournemouth won't care though.
For me too many of our players are under performing, we do need a win, hope it happens against Spurs.

OptimistPesimistt

1.) 31 Oct 2026 17:33:53
Think we are gonna have to have a word with ourselves OP, cos after all of that hype from the opening matches we are starting to look very vulnerable and ineffective going forward. There aint no spark and we are becoming very meh.

Time to step up a level DF and the boys before its too late and we get caught up in a bun fight cos looking at it a large number of points is gonna be required to avoid going down.


2.) 31 Oct 2026 17:44:17
Not sure has this team burnt it self out our captain was poor but than so many others were the same our passing is the worse thing I have seen from this group, this game gives me no confidence for the next six games Farkey will need to wave his wand to sort this out.
I believe 49 will be thinking the same.


3.) 31 Oct 2026 17:54:46
3 very good posts.


4.) 31 Oct 2026 18:06:49
Spot on post Davey Vid.


5.) 31 Oct 2026 18:39:07
I'm not too worried. I think we're regressing to mean. We had a good start. Now we're in the first poor patch. I said if we failed to pick up a win from these two Sunderland and Bournemouth games then it would be an average start after what had initially been a good start.

Three of our next four are tough games. Spurs in form (just like Bournemouth were) , Chelsea. Coventry now looks critical.

But some clubs below us have really tough looking fixtures. The passing looked off today as a few have said.

We still look really hard to beat. The error today and just a late finish. Yes we don't look like scoring and that is a concern. I actually think Wilson started quite well - nice little involvement in dcls offside goal and a fair drive from 25 yards. Not ready to give up on him quite yet. James looked awful could run and his final ball absolutely atrocious.

I trust Farke but I do wish he would rotate a little more. See what bard is about. Give bahoya a bit more than a cameo.

With my friends we all did a full table before opening day of where we think we'll finish. I went for an optimistic 11th. By end of the weekend we'll be there or thereabouts. It's a tough league this year. All the newly promoted are picking up points. The lower teams who made Europe in palace and Sunderland are struggling badly indeed.

Sunderland will be rooted to the table I think with Chelsea spurs villa and Liverpool their next four.

Forest have city Bournemouth Chelsea hull Brighton

Manchester united have villa Liverpool Brentford and Newcastle with Europe too.

My point is there are no easy games anymore. You have either play well, benefit from a red card or mistake or a big piece of fortune to win games. We haven't had much of any of that yet this season (bar GG avoiding a red Vs man u perhaps) .

I expect to see Bahoya given more of a chance soon. Let's see.


6.) 31 Oct 2026 18:45:37
I think Farke needs to give the players the license to be a bit braver, there's the element of risk in that of course but we definitely need to produce some goals, Dominic has literally no service whatsoever.

This does present itself as a challenge for Daniel Farke now, defensively we are still solid but he's got to find a way to open up the opposition. I think he has to gamble a bit, I feel we only need a goal to win a game,
Take that risk in the first twenty minutes with a high press to force the advantage.
I get the feeling we are playing too safe which makes us look ponderous.

If we carry on like this I still don't think we'll end up in a relegation battle, but we won't be far from it. I'm pretty sure Farke will not be happy with the goals drying up, I do expect some tweaking with his game plan at some point.


7.) 31 Oct 2026 19:00:39
Good post that Ealing but we can't put all the pressure on Bohoya to sort out our attacking service.
I think Farke will slowly introduce him with bench starts and that's rightly so in my estimation, he does need to protect him from the already huge expectations put on the young lad.


I want to see some of our other players step up to the plate, they are very clearly underperforming, for instance Stach, he's completely fallen off the map.
We do need a win to inject some much needed energy and confidence.


8.) 31 Oct 2026 20:01:03
Ya it definitely feels at times,Farke hits a wall unable to implement change and just gives the impression that he's happy to draw a game

It seems a very dangerous tactic in such an intense league, Being pragmatic is fine a lot of the time but Farke has a tendency to accept it all too regularly

Again I reiterate thw game v Utd was crying out for a bit of something,yet Farke drowned it out with a very poor oversight of a very weak Utd team

Lose 1-2 more in a row and he's under the kosh big time.


9.) 31 Oct 2026 20:09:20
they'll draw up something new, they have to. Okafor is a flair player but is fairly streaky, Aaronson hard-working and streaky, Wilson continues to adapt, as I said he looked slightly better before trafford's mistake drained any momentum we'd built up.

Teams know about the Bogle-Justin build up now so can plan for it. What might work if when Rodon comes back, if we slot him in at lcb (if he can play that side) and give him license to tandem with GG similar to Justin and Bogle. If we continue to play three at back then the centre backs can do that just at different times.

And he can't be too far away, next int break at the latest surely.


10.) 31 Oct 2026 21:19:57
Again a good post Ealing, I can visualize that with Rodon, not only that I think his presence and leadership on the pitch has been greatly missed.
It could very well be Daniel's ticket to getting us some positive results.
Let's hope so.


11.) 31 Oct 2026 23:46:15
I'll actually back Wilson the most. Historically he was a slow starter for Fulham, it took him time to build into a season. Must be even harder in a new club even if half of Wales plays for Leeds. I reckon he gets one he'll go on a streak of goals/assists.

Again he looked slightly better today before we went behind. There was the James break where he got into a great position James just couldn't pick him out. James I've officially given up on. Its been ages since I remember him doing anything useful. Id give BA more chances than I would James. And Bahoya before BA.

Heck if DCL is struggling through it a bit why not give Nmecha a start. The guy is reportedly unhappy with the playing time. That sometimes lights a fire if the player is good enough. Give him the first half vs. Spurs. If he works out, great. If he doesn't DCL gets a larger rest and comes on at hft fresh vs. a tiring Spurs defence (assuming we are still in the game) .


12.) 01 Nov 2026 07:15:44
Yes i agrée there were some positive signs from Wilson, I guess when many of the other players who are underperforming it's not helping his cause either.

On Spurs next weekend, I'm not completely convinced by their fortunate turnaround, a win against a Jeykell and Hyde Chelsea with their susceptible defense and against a ten man Palace for a large part of the game and their dodgy defense also. They will be pegged back by someone soon.

Nmencha doesn't have many fans on this forum but he definitely can bring something to the table as he did show last season. You could be right in giving Dom a game off to give him an opportunity to showcase himself on our turf.
It is evident that our attacking line up does need some kind of alteration, whether that be player or tactical adjustments.


13.) 01 Nov 2026 12:40:17
I wouldn't call myself a big Nmecha fan either, but I'd give him a chance to put up or shut up. Last season there was no denying he was an excellent super sub with vital goals vs. Everton, Fulham etc. This season he's been given 5 minutes here five minutes there and many of those on a flank than centrally.

I dont especially like him but there is some sympathy there therefore.


 

 

 

OptimistPesimistt's rumour replies

 

Click To View This Thread

26 Jun 2025 07:58:26
You are entitled to your opinion as I am mine and I don’t like your opinions of Meslier and Farke.

OptimistPesimistt

 

 

Click To View This Thread

25 Jun 2025 23:17:58
Yeah right ? is that disrespectful?
You bet your sweet Fanny ass.

OptimistPesimistt

 

 

Click To View This Thread

15 Apr 2025 22:26:12
I’d rather have pope Francis.

OptimistPesimistt

 

 

Click To View This Thread

08 Mar 2025 16:06:51
Harrison has always struggled to reach the levels required to be a Premiership player. Just not good enough and I’m sure he will go back to the MLS as it’s unlikely that he wants to play Championship football which is and always has been his level.

Long contracts are given to a lot of players now so to spread out payments and avoid over spending with PSR.

OptimistPesimistt

 

 

Click To View This Thread

08 Jan 2025 18:17:44
Imagine Meslier playing Champions League with Man United!

OptimistPesimistt

 

 

 

OptimistPesimistt's banter replies

 

Click To View This Thread

13 Nov 2026 07:55:50
Carrick's only fault was to take the job in the first place, but I do understand when your old club come calling as a manager, it's not easy to turn it down. It's as much as the error that Frank Lampard made with Chelsea.
Learn to walk before to run.

OptimistPesimistt

 

 

Click To View This Thread

13 Nov 2026 06:39:32
Dunelm, admittedly their owners and Dof are tragically incompetent, that is the real reason they are where they are and Carrick is perhaps more of a symptom of their real problems.
Like why did they appoint, with respect to Middlesbrough, a manager from Middlesbrough with no managerial experience in the Premiership or European football, it's complete madness.
A ten year old child would probably have a better chance of running that club more successfully.
I mean would they choose another Championship manager to do the job now,
Of course not.
Now people are complaining that his sacking was classless and he should have been given the red carpet treatment !
It seriously does make you scratch your head in utter and total disbelief at what is going on here.

Then some fans moan about our situation, please do me a favour, put your foot in the other shoe and then you will witness real problems within a football club.

I don't see any solutions to Man United problems short term or long term. In my estimation the whole club needs to change from top to bottom and that isn't going to happen overnight if ever at all.

Appointing Mauricio Pochettino Is yet again like sticking selotape on something that is physically broken. They need to break down their old walls and build a new one metaphorically.

OptimistPesimistt

 

 

Click To View This Thread

12 Nov 2026 15:23:56
I find the outpouring of sympathy towards Carrick by fans and pundits quite amusing.
Since when in modern day football have managers/ coach's, whether they were a former player of the club or not shown any love and respect when they are shown the door out.
They are the most disposable people within a football club these days.

Let's not forget Carrick will receive a pay off in the millions for leaving Man United in their worst position in fifty years.

Everyone repeating like sheep that it was a classless sacking, for Gods sake again, since when was a football manager's sacking made classy ? ??‍♂️.

OptimistPesimistt

 

 

Click To View This Thread

11 Nov 2026 20:29:43
I get behind my football team, not against it especially where we are now. This is not 1970 !

OptimistPesimistt

 

 

Click To View This Thread

11 Nov 2026 19:08:56
I think thats pure nonsense, you can't play the whole squad on match day !
Farke picks the players who he thinks will win football matches, it's not personal and absolutely nothing to do with favoritism.

Bijol will have to knuckle down and prove he is better than Elvedi, Tarik and Rodon, that goes for any other fringe players.
Even Joe Rodon in my opinion has his work cut out to better Elvedi and Muharemovic.

That's football and damn right it must be competitive to earn your place.

OptimistPesimistt

 

 





Change Consent