Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded
No Avatar image uploaded
Leeds Rumours Member Posts
OptimistPesimistt's Profile
OptimistPesimistt's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To OptimistPesimistt's Posts
To OptimistPesimistt's last 5 rumours posts
To OptimistPesimistt's last 5 banter posts
To OptimistPesimistt's last 5 rumour replies
To OptimistPesimistt's last 5 banter replies
OptimistPesimistt's rumours posts with other poster's replies to OptimistPesimistt's rumours posts
25 Dec 2024 07:22:11
Looks like it’s Joe Gelhardt the player that is likely to depart for Wrexham in January and not Paddy.
Bamford’s Premiership wages being the problem potentially.
I think for Gelhardt he does need to consider his future career as it doesn’t seem likely at all he’ll get any game time with us, especially if we make it to the Prem.
Good luck to the young man if it happens.
1.) 25 Dec 2024 12:15:23
Joffy definitely better at Wrexham rather than the much touted move to Rangers.
2.) 26 Dec 2024 03:29:01
Yep. Either or. Maybe get 3 mill for him.
Gelhardt that is.
3.) 29 Dec 2024 16:23:45
Sounds like the agents of Mes, Bamford and Geldhardt are putting out stories to see which clubs take the bait.
I hope Geldhardt goes and sets the league on fire. He has some real talent that needs nurturing and he has to do it sooner than later. Leeds have missed the chance with him, best to let him go and grow.
4.) 29 Dec 2024 17:21:54
I would say it’s the other way around to be fair MoT; he has missed a massive chance, not us. I do however he will do as you say, and go on elsewhere, albeit a less competitive arena, and do well.
5.) 30 Dec 2024 09:36:55
Joffy . talented and never given a prolonged proper chance when he was causing panic in opposition defences in EPL . home to Wolvea and Norwich. Played well at Chelsea
But has also had many injuries . and as such he seems to have slowed down and regressed past 2 seasons.
27 Aug 2024 13:39:51
If the Max Aaron’s rumour is true that would be a real scrap for that right back position with Bogle already starting there.
Can’t see it myself but you never know, CB for me would be the more important signing, losing Rodon or Pascal or both at the same time, God forbid could be a hideous situation for us.
1.) 27 Aug 2024 14:25:50
Agree Opti. Cb more important.
Plus ham of course.
2.) 27 Aug 2024 14:30:54
Yep, it would be strange to only have youth cover for those two if Wober is leaving.
3.) 27 Aug 2024 17:43:25
OP If Aarons comes in, Bogle could be deployed RM/ RW as cover, rotation for DJ.
4.) 27 Aug 2024 21:37:41
Aarons can also play left back so he covers us on both sides. Have a feeling we might sell Firpo in January so Aarons and Bogle will end up being first choice.
5.) 28 Aug 2024 22:51:01
God forbid is right.
08 Feb 2023 08:22:40
Hearing that Harrison, Struijk and Bamford won’t be playing tonight, does anyone know if there’s any truth in that?
Losing Bamford again could be a big problem for us.
1.) 08 Feb 2023 09:01:04
Don’t think any of them played well against forest prob for different reasons. Harrison cause of deadline day debarked. Struik cause he can’t play well and Bamford not fully fit.
So no surprise if it’s true. Trouble is except for gnonto and wober everyone was crap so be interesting to see.
Worth giving Tyler Weston and maybe gyabi a go.
See what Rutter can do.
Def don’t even have Aron on bench.
2.) 08 Feb 2023 12:50:57
Rodrigo injury remains a disaster
Thank gawd that Brent has gone. worse than the Hock as all time worst Leeds coach.
3.) 08 Feb 2023 13:12:06
I think that’s fair tbh, all 3 were woeful on Sunday, especially Struijk and Harrison, Bamford was very isolated but still had a stinker. Hopefully he starts a solid 3 in midfield with McKennie replacing Jack and Rutter false 9. Suppose Firpo will start LB but can’t be any worse than Pascal has been lately (I’ll regret saying that by 20:05 tonight I’m sure)
4.) 08 Feb 2023 20:20:35
All 3 starting.
5.) 09 Feb 2023 09:03:53
Sack your snitch opti.
06 Feb 2023 14:37:09
Marsch sacked.
1.) 06 Feb 2023 14:42:12
Now't on Sky but a lot of people saying he's been given the bullet this morning! ?.
2.) 06 Feb 2023 15:00:32
Official.
OptimistPesimistt's banter posts with other poster's replies to OptimistPesimistt's banter posts
20 Jan 2025 22:48:50
Well it looks like desperate Burnley are looking to the future by signing aging journeyman Shelvey to the end of the season.
I really hope nobody says anything really daft like, we should of signed him.
1.) 20 Jan 2025 23:34:25
Nobody saw that one coming that’s for sure OP.
Not a betting man normally but probably poor odds for his first sending off.
2.) 21 Jan 2025 00:02:47
OP Quite the reverse. There appears to be growing transfer noise about us reportedly acquiring Oxford United midfielder Tyler Goodrham. That's definitely more like it imo.
3.) 21 Jan 2025 02:50:07
' desperate' Burnley OP?
So OP most of last season you were very unwisely as it turned out dismissing and knocking ( Gonner) Ipswich and Leicester.
Now you are doing so again this time with Burnley and Sheff Utd.
Hmmm.
4.) 21 Jan 2025 02:56:24
As for Shelvey. a solid very capable player esp at Champo level
And he has always played very well against Leeds United often scoring
A 6 month loan spell a no risk win win for Burnley imo OP.
{Ed001's Note - awful, lazy, poor attitude and his legs have gone. I am shocked anyone would want Voldemort.}
5.) 21 Jan 2025 05:18:52
I don’t dismiss any team in the Championship but plucky, lucky Ipswich did achieve promotion only because our youthful inexperienced squad didn’t have the mental strength to take us over the line. That won’t be our problem this season.
Burnley however for me don’t posses the fire power to get them automatic promotion and if they think Jobjo Shelvey as a midfielder, who does have a decent right peg is their answer to create and score goals, then in my opinion they won’t make it and they are desperate.
His disciplinary record is more likely to be a hindrance to their challenge than anything else.
For me the two teams that will be holding onto our tailcoats will be the Blunts and possibly Sunderland.
Enough of your little stories Baz.
6.) 21 Jan 2025 06:31:00
Fair dos Ed001 I was remembering Shelvey when Leeds played against him which was 3 or more seasons ago
and looking up his recent stats past for 3 seasons they aren't pretty much like his slightly unfortunate appearance that you allude to lol.
{Ed001's Note - he was an absolute joke at Forest. He was terrible at Liverpool as well as his attitude stinks.}
7.) 21 Jan 2025 06:35:32
OP on the flip side to your assertions; it would be foolish of you to dismiss Burnley to finish top 2 seeing as they do NOT concede goals
just 9 goals conceded in 27 matches is remarkable
it means they will pick up 3 points most of time by scoring just 1 goal
it helps too that they have a super goalkeeper unlike Leeds.
8.) 21 Jan 2025 06:48:43
yep he hardly got a game at Forest Ed001 but it Leeds matches with Newcastle that I was basing my opinion and Shelvey played well in them.
9.) 21 Jan 2025 07:11:59
Well that’s that then Baz, he had a few outstanding games against us but since then he’s been rubbish?
I’m glad that’s all cleared up now.
10.) 21 Jan 2025 07:45:45
Best wait till end of season OP. he might have a telling impact in weak Champo.
11.) 21 Jan 2025 08:30:01
Baz Bingo!
Insult OP
Insult Meslier
Goner Ipswich
If only there was some DJ praise and Orta criticism to finish the set.
12.) 21 Jan 2025 08:50:27
Tbf to Burnley it’s probably the best they could do in these tough January transfer windows, considering what is available and not jeopardizing PSR.
In my opinion the only good about the transfer window in January is for teams that have been ravaged by too many injuries and are desperate to take on anybody.
Still think in those circumstances it’s probably better to make the most of your youth players.
13.) 21 Jan 2025 09:10:06
Brockers . a full set from moi would also have to at least include praise for the great Revie Wilko DOL and Bielsa coaches and player legends
Much as I like Dan James he is wayyy behind these men in my admiration.
14.) 21 Jan 2025 09:14:44
OP
BUT last season both Ipswich and Southampton bought in significant midfield, winger and forwards players in Jan window . both went up as a result at the expense of LUFC
pretty sure Sheff Utd, Villa Norwich and Derby did too in Jan 2019 when Leeds missed out on promotion after being top on new years day.
15.) 21 Jan 2025 09:38:04
If you wanted to make an argument you could say Kiefer Moore made some contribution to their promotion. But Ipswich didn’t win promotion, we gave it to them as for reasons I’ve already explained.
Us bringing in an aging journeyman striker and a top quality premiership ready keeper that we can’t afford, would probably make more problems for us than good.
We’re on the right track for glory, why fix what isn’t broken. ?
16.) 21 Jan 2025 10:18:57
I don’t believe our recruitment team are sitting back and not doing anything! When you’ve got what’s arguably the best squad in the division adding to it in the right way isn’t as easy as posting on here! On Saturday all three goals scored by new recruits in the summer who are all looking like very good decisions! For me, assuming no one else goes, a flexible quality defensive option and an alternative 10 would be a good window. Torn a bit on Matteo, I like so much of what he does and with a run, he could really deliver. I’d be tempted to show faith in him knowing his hard work will help create goals for others if he still struggles with scoring.
17.) 21 Jan 2025 11:10:17
George - Oxford are my local team, seen them a few times this year and Goodrahm is definitely not good enough to start for us, he lacks pace and goes missing for the most part. Even my Oxford fan mates don’t particularly rate him.
18.) 21 Jan 2025 12:42:55
Voldemort! Brilliant Ed.
19.) 21 Jan 2025 13:07:30
Good post Spanish.
We have the best squad but lack ambition.
Aus nails it.
20.) 21 Jan 2025 14:28:29
Rambo Thanks for the info. Let's hope we don't buy him then.
12 Jan 2025 07:07:59
I think the game last night pretty much showed that Farke has got it right in his selection of the first eleven.
First off Solomon for me was easily the Man of the Match. He oozes quality and is without doubt our most creative player.
Joseph got a couple of shots at goal and was unlucky to hit the woodwork. You can see he’s a little frustrated and is probably trying too hard to impress. Still think he’ll come good with time and is definitely worth holding on to.
Ramazani also needs to temper his skills, got himself positioned well for his header on goal.
Darlow didn’t do much wrong, did flap at one cross of the ball but did well at his run out to block the ball.
The only player I was disappointed with was Josuha Guilavogui, he looked to me uncomfortable playing in his position, I can see why for the moment Farke only brings him on as a late sub.
Great to see Greuev back, we’re pretty much now back to full strength, looks very promising for the second part of the season.
Top of the league and still in the FA Cup, can’t ask for more in my humble opinion.
1.) 12 Jan 2025 08:35:19
Can’t argue with that opti. Thought thought gman generally dm.
2.) 12 Jan 2025 09:00:50
Agree OP, thought Big G looked very uncomfortable and got caught the wrong side on a couple of occasions, but still a quality addition, especially in midfield.
Really disappointed with MJ again, he keeps getting opportunities to shine, and none better than against a league 2 team at Elland Road, but his decision making is poor. Some of his runs are into the wrong channels (look at McAtee yesterday, different gravy when you look at his decision making) , and how many times does he put his head down and it’s route one to goal, when better options are to his side. Maybe if that one that hit the post went in, he could have stepped on and scored a couple, but he isn’t getting any success at the moment.
I hope he comes good, and there is a good player in there, but I don’t think we can rely on him to push us into the Premier League. I hope the board are looking at bring in a CF asap!
3.) 12 Jan 2025 09:43:02
Gman was not comfortable last night he is not a CB definitely in my opinion needs playing as DM he was slow and easily outplayed even by a team we should have controlled easily and that is no disrespect to Harrogate who played very well last night had their attack been as good as their defence we would have been in trouble. Solly was definitely on the ball but I was more impressed by Issac who was excellent and should be given a run in my opinion not that it will happen as DF will put Bogle straight back in. Darlow (ego I have criticised in the past) had a good enough game to keep his place.
Anyway onwards and upwards we are looking good just now.
Last thing is I still believe we need a striker Bambi will never return to the player he once was and MJ for all his efforts is at this moment not good enough, that leaves Piroe only, if he is injured we are struggling in that department.
4.) 12 Jan 2025 10:11:35
Yep some good fair points made by OP Aus MG and Old Bri.
5.) 12 Jan 2025 10:12:31
Who I not ego?
6.) 12 Jan 2025 14:55:15
OP We ask for KD between the sticks and not the ????.
7.) 12 Jan 2025 18:28:34
I’d go for KM Kyle Minogue but KD isn’t going to cut the mustard.
Sorry.
11 Jan 2025 08:17:42
We’ve had a shocking history against fourth tier clubs in the cups over recent years. It’s also very rare that we get a home tie also.
Time to put this hoodoo to bed and a great opportunity for some of the fringe players to show what they’ve got.
Hope this fixture isn’t canceled due to the Icy conditions?
1.) 11 Jan 2025 10:25:40
Our record is poor against League 2 sides, so as you say, a chance for some fringe players to shine. A couple of goals for Joseph would do him the world of good. A convincing win, no injuries and a good pay day for Harrogate would be the perfect outcome today.
09 Jan 2025 09:41:29
Recently have been reflecting on three players in particular, Bamford, Phillips and Harrison and how Bielsa had transformed them from mediocre Championship players to two of them receiving England caps.
It’s also perhaps very noticeable that the careers of these three players have declined back into obscurity without him.
I often wonder why after being taught techniques to enhance their game, why they couldn’t continue on the same plateau, ? instead their skills and techniques it would seem have evaded them to the point that they have very clearly regressed enormously.
Some may say perhaps that Bielsa could have cut their careers short by over training them. It would seem that Bamford and Phillips have been blighted by many injuries since, or was that just coincidence?
1.) 09 Jan 2025 10:40:36
None of them were ever ' mediocre Champo level' before being coached by Bielsa
But Bielsa definitely improved all 3's performances and all 3 had quite a lot of very good performances in EPL
and Bielsa definitely improved the confidence of JH and KP
Bamford confidence however has always been shaky and not sure even Bielsa could improve it that much
no surprise at all that Bamford had his best season by far playing in empty stadiums covid season 20/ 21 . he was absolutely superb that season.
2.) 09 Jan 2025 11:20:10
Why reflect on these players at all? Especially when there's a far more relevant and pressing matter of a player to deal with and replace in Meslier?
3.) 09 Jan 2025 12:27:32
Much as I praise Bielsa OP I do believe there was a consequence in particular for Bamford playing under the relentless standards expected under Marcelo.
I believe for both Phillips and Harrison it was much more a loss of confidence, both joined the wrong clubs, sure KP would have experienced impostor syndrome at City and Harrison went to a club under Dyche that have no desire to play football.
The fact that Leicester were going to give us £22million for Harrison before 49ers blocked it, that’s a good keeper and left back right there.
4.) 09 Jan 2025 13:07:47
It’s reasonable to believe that Class.
George, there’s only so much you can discuss on Meslier before it just becomes a very over used topic. As for the rest of the crap journalism of who we are going to buy or loan, take your pick because we could possibly create an entire league with those amount of players.
I’ll just wait to see what the outcome will be on 1st February, in my opinion there will be very little to talk about on incomings, then it will be the moaning slanging match that will commence.
Baz, definitely average Championship players pre Bielsa., sorry you’re wrong again.
5.) 09 Jan 2025 15:09:33
Nah OP. ALL were above "mediocre " definitely
But anyways brother George is 100% right its irrelevant with fare more pressing matters
We have a stubborn foolish coach who is going to ridiculously persist with cooked Meslier in goal
Farke OUT.
6.) 09 Jan 2025 19:43:26
Interesting to hear what people think of Brokenford now? Injured now again, the man has absolutely stole a living these last 3 years and for all seasons he's been with us, there's only 1 he was good in, yet here we are now again paying out for a crock
Now reading comments last week, some feel it's wrong to have a go at any Leeds player or manager,
It's now jaw dropping to know that Paddy'collects a Lottery win every month for not playing and is a really poor footballer .
I understand he's in contract, but surely the respect some people feel players automatically deserve should work from players to fans / club also ? He has to know we ain't a rich club yet he has no problems taking cash for nothing
Why not decline the huge packet? Why not let those funds be spent on another player? Why not retire?
It's all about respect seemingly.
7.) 09 Jan 2025 19:50:17
Very fair comment Chrissy
If only.
8.) 09 Jan 2025 21:14:06
Hello ? CC. Nice ? to see you.
9.) 09 Jan 2025 21:14:55
Baz Kagey has been in imperious form last few videos. Thinks like you and me.
10.) 09 Jan 2025 22:07:39
Thank you Blanco, been lurking awhile not posting, but seeing as it is getting to nitty gritty time I will get back on saddle again.
05 Jan 2025 08:00:44
Top of the league, that's all that matters to me in this very uncompetitive low quality league.
I’ve said my bit about Farke and Meslier and I stand by it, even if it is unpopular. I’m not going to repeat my opinions on here again.
1.) 05 Jan 2025 08:22:36
But OP! You must repeat them! It’s the law! Repeat, repeat, repeat! We are all too Effin’ stupid in here to remember people’s views after all! And then, we need praise, lots of it, if our repetitive predictions of doom and failure come to fruition, as we never got praise as kids for anything, and are psychologically damaged as a result!
Remember, I said it first! Farke out!
2.) 05 Jan 2025 08:34:56
OP it’s good to have your opinion, and yes we are top of the league but for how long if we do not change things it’s a dead duck one two or three mistake you might just say it happens but he has to go . even you must see that.
3.) 05 Jan 2025 08:40:12
It’s all about opinions OP and yours is just as important as everybody else’s, and a big yes we are still top of the league and will be after the FA Cup which is huge, keep going OP ??.
4.) 05 Jan 2025 08:50:47
If we keep discussing the same topic. Goes without saying all will be repetitive.
5.) 05 Jan 2025 09:33:41
Aus I think pretty much every poster on this forum has their opinion already on Farke and Mez, whether that's good or bad.
Therefore for me, this subject it’s now just become repetition with nothing new to add.
Like I’ve said before, in how many ways can you say, get rid of Mez and Farke now.
Especially Meslier, has anyone considered how it could destabilize the way we play by bringing in a new keeper in January, is it that simple and are all our problems resolved by doing that?
Nobody is talking about our poor performance in the the first half, then go on the rampage in the second half then towards the end of the game we inexplicably switch off. What about the outfield players, why were they incapable of keeping possession in those last ten minutes?
For me it’s too easy to say we lost because it was Meslier’s fault, there are eleven players on that pitch, not just one and they are all culpable if the game isn’t played out in the right manner to win those three points.
6.) 05 Jan 2025 12:30:00
I believe it’s a clear case of cause and effect.
When Illan continues to make new and highly damaging errors the obvious effect is that people will discuss the need to rectify the issue.
We are all familiar with the definition of insanity… Insanity Is Doing the Same Thing Over and Over Again and Expecting Different Results.
Goalkeeping has been an Achilles heel for Leeds United for many seasons now, and for the life of me I cannot comprehend how we’re happy to spend £30 million plus on a flair player but shell out pennies on our keepers?
7.) 05 Jan 2025 14:15:21
Op yes we understand all about bringing in a new keeper but surely you can see that destabilise is there already the defensive team don’t trust him. His action has destabilising the hole team there body language tells us that how much more do you need need to see this not going up or middle table may convince you but I don’t think anything will the saying is burying your head in the sand.
8.) 05 Jan 2025 14:22:55
OP Go buy us a new GK.
9.) 05 Jan 2025 14:36:24
Spot on post Whitey very well said.
10.) 05 Jan 2025 18:52:34
I can say one thing, there’s no way that you can be top of the league with an inaffective goalkeeper. It’s just not possible in my opinion.
OptimistPesimistt's rumour replies
08 Jan 2025 18:17:44
Imagine Meslier playing Champions League with Man United!
OptimistPesimistt's banter replies
23 Jan 2025 18:01:57
Likely and logical in your space of mind as a Leeds fan but definitely not mine Baz.
I’m expecting a win and that’s not a rose tinted view, that's simply based on how the two teams are performing right now. That’s including their 5-0 win against Plymouth last night which is a good win against the worst team in the Championship, but will have absolutely no bearing on our game with them.
They can’t score goals but they seem to be good at getting 0-0 draws.
Please understand when I say in English, ( it will ”NOT” be an easy game) ! It is about the third or fourth time I have said this in different posts.
But it’s one we will win or at worst draw.
Onwards and Upwards or in your translation
Backwards and Downwards.
23 Jan 2025 15:39:32
I think if you were that sincere you would be predicting us to win against Burnley or at least a draw.
We are not playing Liverpool at Anfield, can you not see any remote chance of us getting a result against the Mighty Burnley?
You can still change your mind Baz.
23 Jan 2025 13:34:04
Yes I hope you’re wrong again Baz with the Burnley game. Fancy tipping your team to lose, disappointing and absolutely nothing to do with reality, facts or stats.
We are Leeds and we are top of the League.
23 Jan 2025 13:30:00
You’re absolutely right Class, great vision and bargaining by the recruitment.
Wilder was sick at losing Bogle to us, part of the reason why he’s been so vindictive and spicy towards us in his interviews.
23 Jan 2025 13:21:23
The congrats must also go to Farke and his coaching staff as his escalation of form and his goal scoring ability is attributed to them surely.
Long may it continue.